Two undefeated Quad-A state champions. Two legendary coaches. Two neighboring football powerhouses separated by one season. But which team was actually better?
There are certain debates in Western Pennsylvania sports history that will probably never be settled.
Who had the greatest WPIAL football team ever? Which era produced the toughest competition? And what would happen if two legendary teams from different seasons actually lined up against each other?
One matchup I’ve always found fascinating is the 1994 McKeesport Tigers against the 1995 Penn Hills Indians.
Both teams finished 15-0. Both won WPIAL and PIAA Class AAAA championships. And both accomplished something extremely difficult during an era when Quad-A football in Western Pennsylvania was loaded with talent.
But what makes this hypothetical matchup so interesting isn’t just their records. It’s how differently these teams were built, the legendary coaches leading them, and the possibility that one of the greatest defenses in WPIAL history could have faced one of its most productive rushing attacks.
If George Smith’s 1994 McKeesport Tigers faced Neil Gordon’s 1995 Penn Hills Indians, who would win?
The 1994 McKeesport Tigers: George Smith’s Championship Formula
George Smith believed in a brand of football that wasn’t complicated.
Run the football. Control the clock. Play outstanding defense. And make opponents earn everything they get.
His wishbone offense became synonymous with McKeesport football, and in 1994, the Tigers executed that system at a championship level.
McKeesport captured its first WPIAL championship since 1938 by defeating Upper St. Clair, 21-14. But the Tigers weren’t finished.
They survived a 7-6 battle against Erie Central in the state playoffs before facing nationally ranked Downingtown for the PIAA championship.
Trailing late in the fourth quarter, McKeesport put together a championship-winning drive. Quarterback Bill Isbir scored on an 11-yard run, giving the Tigers a 17-14 victory and their first PIAA state championship.
That team wasn’t built around one spectacular offensive player. It was built around execution, discipline, and a defense that could completely disrupt opposing offenses.
McKeesport allowed fewer than eight points per game and recorded four shutouts. And at the center of that defense was Brandon Short.
Short was one of the greatest linebackers to come out of Western Pennsylvania. He eventually became an All-American at Penn State and spent seven seasons in the NFL. But in 1994, he was the defensive leader of a team that made scoring points extremely difficult.
That’s what made McKeesport dangerous. The Tigers didn’t need to score 40 points to beat you.
Sometimes 14 or 17 was enough.
The 1995 Penn Hills Indians: Two Running Backs and a Dominant Offensive Line
Now let’s move forward one season. Neil Gordon’s 1995 Penn Hills Indians were a different kind of offensive powerhouse.
And being from Penn Hills, I understand what that team meant to the community. But I’m not going to allow my hometown connection to influence this comparison. The accomplishments speak for themselves.
Penn Hills featured one of the most productive running back combinations in WPIAL history. DeWayne Thompson and Victor Strader. Both rushed for more than 1,600 yards during the 1995 season.
Think about how unusual that is.
Most high school teams would be thrilled to have one running back produce those numbers. Penn Hills had two. And neither would have enjoyed that success without the offensive line creating opportunities.
That was the foundation of the Indians’ offense.
Quarterback Len Gilmer attempted only 57 passes during the entire season. Penn Hills wasn’t trying to fool opponents with an elaborate passing attack. Everybody knew the Indians wanted to run the football.
The challenge was stopping them.
Penn Hills defeated Upper St. Clair, 20-13, in the WPIAL championship game. The Indians followed that victory with a 28-0 shutout of McDowell in the state semifinals before defeating Lower Dauphin, 35-14, for the PIAA championship. That season cemented Penn Hills as one of the greatest teams in school history.
But how would that offense have performed against McKeesport’s defense?
That’s where this debate becomes interesting.
The Matchup Within the Matchup: Brandon Short vs. Penn Hills’ Offensive Line
If these teams had actually played, this is the battle I would have paid the most attention to.
Brandon Short and McKeesport’s defensive front against Penn Hills’ offensive line. Short had the instincts, physical ability, and football intelligence to disrupt a running game.
But Penn Hills presented a difficult challenge because opponents couldn’t concentrate on stopping just one running back. Thompson and Strader could both hurt a defense.
If McKeesport committed too many defenders to one side, Penn Hills had the personnel to attack somewhere else.
On the other hand, the Tigers had already demonstrated they could handle outstanding rushing attacks. In the 1994 state championship game, McKeesport made a critical goal-line stand against a Downingtown team that featured two 1,000-yard rushers. That experience would have been valuable against Penn Hills.
But there’s a difference between defending a talented backfield and controlling it for four quarters.
Could McKeesport consistently win at the line of scrimmage? Could Penn Hills establish enough of a running game to keep the Tigers’ defense on the field?
Those questions would have determined much of this matchup.
And I believe the answer would have come down to which offensive line performed better.
Could Penn Hills Stop McKeesport’s Wishbone?
Everybody would naturally focus on Penn Hills’ running backs against McKeesport’s defense.
But there’s another side to this matchup.
How would Penn Hills have defended George Smith’s wishbone offense? That system demanded discipline.
Defenders had to recognize their assignments, maintain their responsibilities, and avoid getting caught out of position. One mistake could lead to a big gain.
And McKeesport had spent years perfecting that approach.
The Tigers weren’t going to abandon their offense because an opponent had talented defensive players. They were going to keep running it until somebody proved they could stop it. Penn Hills would have needed its defensive front to control the interior while preventing McKeesport from getting outside.
That’s easier said than done.
And with both teams relying heavily on the running game, field position and turnovers would have been extremely important.
A fumble near midfield could change the entire game. A long drive could take several minutes off the clock.
And one defensive stop could be the difference between winning and losing.
George Smith vs. Neil Gordon: Two Legendary Coaches
Another reason I love this hypothetical matchup is the coaching battle.
George Smith and Neil Gordon were two of the most respected football coaches in Western Pennsylvania.
Both understood how to build successful programs. Both demanded discipline. And both believed in physical football. But their greatest challenge in this game would have been making adjustments.
What happens if Penn Hills struggles to run between the tackles? What happens if McKeesport’s wishbone isn’t producing the big plays it normally creates? Which coach changes his approach first? And which team responds better when its original game plan isn’t working?
Those are the situations where great coaching becomes especially important.
I don’t believe either coach would have panicked. Both had experienced enough difficult games to understand that championship football often requires patience.
And sometimes the smartest decision is trusting your players to execute what they’ve practiced all season.
One Interesting Connection Between These Teams
Here’s something that makes this comparison even more intriguing.
Both teams defeated Upper St. Clair in their respective WPIAL championship games. McKeesport won, 21-14, in 1994. Penn Hills won, 20-13, in 1995. Both victories came by seven points.
Now, I’m not suggesting that identical margins mean the teams were equally talented. Upper St. Clair had different personnel in those seasons, and every football game has its own circumstances.
But it’s still an interesting connection between two consecutive state champions.
Both had to survive a difficult WPIAL championship game before going on to win a state title. And both proved they could handle pressure when their seasons were on the line.
So Who Was Actually Better?
This is where I think the debate becomes difficult.
If you’re choosing McKeesport, your strongest argument is its defense. The Tigers had an outstanding linebacker in Brandon Short, a disciplined defensive unit, and an offensive system capable of controlling possession. McKeesport also demonstrated its ability to win close games against outstanding competition.
But if you’re choosing Penn Hills, the argument starts with its offensive line and backfield. Thompson and Strader combined for more than 3,200 rushing yards. That’s extraordinary production, especially against the competition Penn Hills faced. The Indians also showed how explosive their offense could be, scoring 35 points in the state championship game.
But I don’t think comparing championship-game scores tells the entire story.
McKeesport faced a different opponent with different strengths. Penn Hills did the same.
And sometimes the most dominant team isn’t necessarily the one that wins by the largest margin. It’s the team that consistently finds a way to beat whoever is standing across from it.
That’s why I believe this matchup would have been decided in the fourth quarter.
I could see both teams struggling to establish their running games early before eventually finding something that worked.
And I wouldn’t be surprised if one turnover or one big defensive play decided the outcome.
A Debate That Deserves to Be Had
I grew up understanding what Penn Hills football represented. That 1995 championship team remains one of the proudest moments in the program’s history.
But I also have tremendous respect for what George Smith built at McKeesport. The 1994 Tigers were outstanding.
And when you compare these teams, I think it’s important to remember how competitive the old Quad-A classification was.
Winning a WPIAL championship during that era was difficult enough. Going undefeated and winning a state championship was an entirely different accomplishment.
Both programs did it in consecutive seasons. That’s remarkable.
If I had to identify the biggest factor in this hypothetical game, it wouldn’t be the quarterbacks, running backs, or even the coaching staffs.
It would be the line of scrimmage.
Could Penn Hills’ offensive line consistently move McKeesport’s defensive front? Or would Brandon Short and the Tigers disrupt the Indians’ rushing attack enough to take control?
That’s the matchup I’d want to see.
And while I have my own thoughts about how it might unfold, I’m not going to declare a winner. I’d rather hear from the people who watched both teams.
Especially the former players, coaches, and fans who remember just how talented these programs were.
WPIAL WHAT IF? Episode 2: 1994 McKeesport vs. 1995 Penn Hills.
Two undefeated state champions. Two legendary coaches. One hypothetical showdown.
Who wins, and what’s your final score?
DrewSchifino.com — Preserving Western Pennsylvania sports history, one story at a time.