Barry Church: The Penn Hills NFL Standout Who Doesn’t Get Nearly Enough Recognition

When you start discussing the greatest football players to come out of Penn Hills, there are certain names that immediately come to mind.

Aaron Donald. Bill Fralic. Some of the legendary players who helped build one of the richest football traditions in Western Pennsylvania.

But there’s another name I believe gets overlooked far too often.

Barry Church.

A former Penn Hills standout who became one of the most decorated defensive players in University of Toledo history before spending nine seasons in the NFL with the Dallas Cowboys and Jacksonville Jaguars. I don’t know why his name doesn’t come up more often when people discuss the great athletes our community has produced.

Maybe it’s because he played college football in the Mid-American Conference instead of the Big Ten or SEC. Maybe it’s because he wasn’t a first-round draft pick or a regular on national highlight shows.

Whatever the reason, his career deserves a closer look.

 

From Penn Hills to Toledo

Church was an outstanding all-around athlete during his high school career at Penn Hills.

As a senior, he recorded 80 tackles, nine sacks, and four interceptions while also contributing offensively with 30 receptions for 670 yards and four touchdowns.

He earned second-team Class AAAA All-State honors and was selected to the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review’s Terrific 25 team.

Those numbers tell you something about his versatility. He wasn’t simply a defensive back who could cover receivers. He was physical enough to make plays around the line of scrimmage and athletic enough to contribute on both sides of the football.

Following high school, Church accepted an opportunity to play at Toledo.

For some athletes, attending a Mid-American Conference school means playing outside the national spotlight. But the MAC has a long history of producing outstanding NFL talent, and Church would become another example.

 

One of the Greatest Defensive Players in Toledo History

What Church accomplished at Toledo from 2006 through 2009 was remarkable.

He became the first player in school history to earn first-team All-MAC honors in four consecutive seasons. That’s an achievement that deserves recognition by itself.

Most college football players spend their freshman seasons adjusting to the speed and physicality of the game.

Church arrived ready to contribute.

He earned conference recognition as a freshman and continued performing at that level throughout his entire college career. By the time he finished at Toledo, he had accumulated 354 tackles, nine interceptions, 26 tackles for loss, six forced fumbles, and three blocked kicks. He was also named a semifinalist for the Jim Thorpe Award, presented annually to the nation’s top defensive back.

One of his most memorable college moments came against Northern Illinois when he blocked two kicks, including a potential game-winning field goal in the closing seconds of a 20-19 Toledo victory.

His contributions eventually earned him induction into the University of Toledo Athletic Hall of Fame in 2016.

When you consider the number of talented football players who have passed through that university, that honor speaks volumes.

 

The NFL Draft Didn’t Define His Future

Despite an outstanding college career, Church wasn’t selected in the 2010 NFL Draft. The Dallas Cowboys signed him as an undrafted free agent.

I’ve always respected athletes who take that route because there’s very little room for error.

A drafted player usually enters training camp with an organization already having invested a selection in him. An undrafted player has to convince coaches that he belongs on the roster.

Church earned his opportunity initially through special teams and gradually worked his way into Dallas’ defensive rotation.

His progress was interrupted in 2012 when he suffered a torn Achilles tendon early in the season.

For a defensive back whose job depends on speed, movement, and reaction time, that type of injury can be devastating.

But Church returned the following season and became a full-time starter.

In 2013, he recorded 135 tackles, establishing himself as one of the Cowboys’ most productive defensive players. He followed that with another strong season in 2014, recording 97 tackles.

Eventually, he became a defensive captain.

That’s a tremendous climb for somebody who entered the league without hearing his name called on draft day.

 

A New Chapter in Jacksonville

After seven seasons in Dallas, Church signed with the Jacksonville Jaguars in 2017.

The timing couldn’t have been much better.

Jacksonville assembled one of the NFL’s most dominant defenses that season, featuring players such as Jalen Ramsey, A.J. Bouye, Calais Campbell, and Malik Jackson.

Church became an important part of that secondary. He recorded four interceptions during the regular season as Jacksonville finished 10-6 and won the AFC South.

One of his biggest individual moments came against the Pittsburgh Steelers at Heinz Field. Church intercepted Ben Roethlisberger and returned the football 51 yards for a touchdown during Jacksonville’s 30-9 victory.

For a player who grew up in Penn Hills, scoring a defensive touchdown against the hometown NFL franchise had to be a memorable achievement.

The Jaguars eventually advanced to the AFC Championship Game, where they lost a close contest to Tom Brady and the New England Patriots.

Church played one more season in Jacksonville before his NFL career came to an end in 2018.

 

How We Measure Greatness

Here’s something I’ve always believed about sports.

Sometimes we get so caught up discussing the greatest players of all time that we overlook how difficult it is just to become a successful professional athlete.

We judge everybody against the absolute best. If a football player doesn’t make multiple Pro Bowls or become a household name, people sometimes act like his career wasn’t anything special.

I disagree with that mentality.

There’s a reason the average NFL career is relatively short. The competition is relentless, injuries are common, and every year another group of talented young players enters the league looking to take somebody’s job.

Church survived that environment for nearly a decade.

He wasn’t a player who simply made a roster and disappeared. He started 90 regular-season games, contributed to playoff teams, and earned leadership responsibilities within one of the most recognizable franchises in professional sports.

That deserves respect.

And it raises a bigger question about how we remember athletes from Western Pennsylvania.

Are we giving enough recognition to the players who had excellent careers without becoming national superstars?

 

Another Reason to Be Proud of Penn Hills

Growing up in Penn Hills, I saw firsthand how much athletic talent came through our community.

We had tremendous football players, basketball players, track athletes, and competitors across numerous sports. Some received national attention while others built impressive careers without much publicity.

That’s part of what motivates me to write about Western Pennsylvania sports history.

I enjoy revisiting the careers of athletes who accomplished something significant, especially when I believe their stories haven’t been discussed enough.

Barry Church belongs in that conversation.

He represented Penn Hills at the high school level, established himself as an elite college defensive player, overcame a serious injury, and built a successful professional career.

And he did it without the advantage of being a highly drafted NFL prospect.

To me, that says a lot about his ability, preparation, and perseverance.

I’m not writing this to suggest he was better than every other great football player to come through Penn Hills. That’s an entirely different debate.

I’m writing it because his accomplishments stand on their own.

Barry Church is one of the most accomplished football players Penn Hills has produced, and his name deserves to be remembered alongside the other greats from our community.

Sometimes giving somebody their flowers isn’t about introducing people to an athlete they’ve never heard of.

It’s about reminding them just how good that athlete really was.

Related Post

Lou Cerro Deserves His Flowers: Four WPIAL Championships and Over 200 Career Wins

When people discuss the greatest high school football coaches in WPIAL history, certain names always

Brian Mangiafico: The Magic Man Who Took Pennsylvania High School Football by Storm in 1991

When you go back through Western Pennsylvania high school football history, you come across players

John Smith: Building More Than a Basketball Program at Laurel Highlands

When people talk about Laurel Highlands basketball, the conversation often starts with the program’s championship

Q&A: Clairton Basketball Coach Rashawd Hatten Talks Bringing Pride Back to the Court, Mon Valley Basketball, and Building a Program Beyond Wins

When people think about Clairton athletics, football is usually the first sport that comes to

Q&A: Jonathan Baldwin: Before the NFL, Aliquippa Produced One of the Most Physically Gifted Athletes Western Pennsylvania Has Ever Seen

When you talk about the greatest athletes to ever come out of Aliquippa, Pennsylvania, you’re

Rich Bonnaure: A Championship Coach, But an Even Better Person — Why the Former South Fayette Coach Deserves His Flowers

When people discuss the greatest basketball coaches in WPIAL history, the conversation usually revolves around

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *