John Smith: Building More Than a Basketball Program at Laurel Highlands

When people talk about Laurel Highlands basketball, the conversation often starts with the program’s championship tradition and some of the outstanding players who have worn a Mustangs uniform.

Rodney Gallagher is certainly one of those names.

But behind every successful basketball program are coaches who understand that building something meaningful requires more than talented players. It takes patience, commitment, accountability, and a willingness to keep working even when the results aren’t showing up on the scoreboard.

That’s something Laurel Highlands boys basketball coach John Smith understands firsthand.

Smith’s journey into coaching wasn’t necessarily a conventional one. Growing up in the area, he loved basketball but didn’t always have the opportunity to participate in organized leagues. Instead of allowing those circumstances to diminish his passion, he eventually found another way to become involved in the game.

He became a coach.

Starting in recreational and church leagues, Smith gradually worked his way through AAU basketball, middle school, and junior varsity before eventually becoming the head coach at Laurel Highlands.

And his first season certainly tested him. The Mustangs finished 2-20. For a coach working under a one-year contract, that kind of record could have easily meant the end of his opportunity.

But Smith’s approach was about establishing standards that went beyond winning games. His players competed hard, represented their community with pride, and refused to quit regardless of the score.

The improvement eventually followed.

Laurel Highlands went from two victories in Smith’s first season to five the following year before winning 13 games and earning a WPIAL playoff berth last season.

Now, with another season approaching, Smith believes the foundation is becoming stronger throughout the entire program, from the elementary levels to the varsity team.

He also brings a unique perspective to coaching because he’s experienced the game as both a coach and a father. His children have competed at the collegiate level, giving him firsthand experience with the challenges of college athletics and the importance of understanding that success isn’t limited to Division I basketball.

One thing that stood out to me during this conversation was Smith’s willingness to discuss the unrealistic expectations that sometimes surround young athletes today.

It’s a subject I’ve talked about quite often myself.

With social media, AAU basketball, and the constant pursuit of exposure, the relationship between parents, players, and coaches has become increasingly complicated.

Smith doesn’t shy away from that conversation.

He also shares some great memories of coaching Rodney Gallagher, reflects on the toughest players and coaches he’s faced throughout the WPIAL, and explains what he hopes people remember about him when his coaching career eventually ends.

I appreciate Coach Smith taking the time to answer these 11 questions and offer some insight into his journey and the future of Laurel Highlands basketball.

 

Q: Coach, let’s start with your journey. What originally inspired you to get into coaching, and how did your path eventually lead you to becoming the head basketball coach at Laurel Highlands?

John Smith: I have always had a deep love for the game of basketball. Times were different when I was growing up. I was the oldest of four children and grew up in the patch. My parents couldn’t always get me to practices and games. Quite honestly, playing organized basketball just wasn’t in the cards for me. But that never stopped me from loving the game, learning the game, and finding ways to be around it. As I got older and my own children became old enough to play, I saw an opportunity to give back to the game that had always meant so much to me. That’s when I started coaching. I began in recreational leagues and church leagues, moved into AAU basketball, then middle school, JV, and eventually became a head coach. I worked my way up through every level, learning along the way and gaining experience at each stop. My journey has always been about my love for the game and wanting to make a difference for the kids who get the opportunities that I didn’t have growing up.

 

Q: Laurel Highlands has a passionate basketball community and a proud tradition. What makes coaching at Laurel Highlands special, and what does representing that community mean to you?

John Smith: Honestly, it means a lot to me. I want people to respect our district and take pride in what we are building. We’ve been through some rough patches, but I truly believe we’re headed in the right direction. To know that I am only the fourth head basketball coach in the history of this school is pretty special. I didn’t know a whole lot about Coach Taylor, but over time I’ve learned more and heard some great stories. Coach Mark John, our current AD, was almost a hero to me growing up. His passion for the game and his fun-loving personality were contagious. They don’t make them like that anymore. Then there’s Coach Hauger, who took me under his wing and gave me my first opportunity within the school district. He taught me so much about what it means to be a head coach, and I’ll forever be grateful that he believed in me and gave me that opportunity. At the end of the day, representing this district is why I do what I do. This is my home. This is where I grew up, where I have so many memories, and where I want to make a difference. I bleed red, white, and blue.

 

Q: Every successful coach has a philosophy that defines his program. When people watch a John Smith-coached team, what do you want them to recognize about the way your players compete?

John Smith: I want us to play hard, fast, and tough. That’s the identity I want our program to have. In my first season as head coach, we went 2-20. I was working under a one-year contract, and honestly, I thought that might be the end of the road for me. But what happened was quite the opposite. I received more support than ever because of the way our players conducted themselves. Regardless of the score, those boys played hard. They competed, they never quit, and they carried themselves like gentlemen. They represented their school, their families, and their community in a way people could be proud of. One of the greatest compliments I’ve ever received as a coach was hearing someone say they loved that our team played hard and gave everything they had, regardless of the score. That meant more to me than they probably realized. The following season, we more than doubled our win total, finishing 5-17. Last year, we took another big step forward, winning 13 games and earning a playoff spot in a very competitive 5A section. We’ve made progress, but our identity hasn’t changed. We are going to give 110% every time we step on the floor. We will control what we can control: our effort, our attitudes, our toughness, and the way we represent Laurel Highlands. We’ll prepare, compete, play together, and leave everything we have on that court. We’ll let the results take care of themselves.

 

Q: Laurel Highlands has produced some outstanding basketball talent over the years, including Rodney Gallagher. What made Gallagher such a special player, and what impact did he have on the program and the younger players who watched him?

John Smith: Rodney is such a great competitor and, more importantly, a great person. I have been very close with him and his family since he was a little boy. In fact, I golfed with his dad today! Rodney was the ultimate competitor. He always put in the work, and it was so rewarding to watch that dedication pay off. Being a part of his high school career was truly a blessing. We made so many great memories together. I’ll never forget waking Rodney and Bronny up on my couch in the mornings so they could get up and go to the gym with my kids! Those are the kinds of memories that stick with you. The 2020 WPIAL run, coming in as the eighth seed and winning it all, and then the 2022 run, finishing with an undefeated WPIAL season, were both incredibly special. Rodney was not only a tremendous player but also a great role model for so many young kids in our area. It was an exciting time to be a Mustang, and I’m grateful I got to be a part of it. Those are memories I’ll always cherish!

 

Q: Building a successful program is one thing, but maintaining that success after talented players graduate is another challenge. How do you establish a culture that allows Laurel Highlands to remain competitive year after year?

John Smith: Success is earned. I believe you have to put the work in if you want to see results. I don’t give the boys much time off throughout the year because I believe consistency and commitment are important. Spring and summer leagues, team camps, open gyms, weight training, fall leagues, and shootouts all play an important role in our development. We’re grinding for most of the year because getting better doesn’t happen overnight. It’s about building habits, developing chemistry, learning to compete, and holding ourselves accountable. When the season comes around, I want our boys to know they’ve put in the work and are prepared for the challenges ahead.

 

Q: You’ve had the opportunity to coach against some talented players and outstanding coaches throughout the WPIAL. Who are some of the toughest players you’ve had to prepare for, and what made them so difficult to defend?

John Smith: Wow, great question! Man, I’ve had the opportunity to see some absolute studs over the years. DeRose’s Penn Hills teams immediately come to mind. Blundo’s 2022 team with Wells, and Coach B’s teams with Thomas and Cummins were nightmares to prepare for. Well-coached athletes are tough to defend! As far as players during my tenure as head coach, I’d have to say Federico from CV. He can beat you inside and outside. Long, bouncy, and extremely skilled. Mykel from Gateway had a lot of the same attributes as Luca. Lastly, I’d have to go with Elsworth from Uniontown. That kid could literally pull up from anywhere, and if he got hot, you were in for a long night!

 

Q: High school basketball has changed considerably with transfers, AAU basketball, social media, and increased exposure. What do you believe is the biggest challenge facing high school basketball coaches today?

John Smith: Social media, mediocre AAU programs, poor competition, and a lack of understanding of the game have created a pretty unrealistic perception of where some players actually stand. Everyone thinks their kid is a Division I player, and if the coach would just do this or that, everyone would finally see it. Unfortunately, those attitudes and conversations don’t stay between the adults. They get communicated to the kids, and that’s where the problems begin. Kids start questioning coaching, playing time, roles, and accountability instead of focusing on getting better and helping their team. There is nothing wrong with believing in your child or wanting the best for them. But there’s a difference between supporting your child and feeding them unrealistic expectations. Sometimes the best thing a parent can do is let their child be coached, encourage them to work, and allow the game to teach them where they stand.

 

Q: As a former player myself, I’ve always believed that talent can only take an athlete so far. What separates a talented high school basketball player from one who has the discipline and mentality to succeed at the college level?

John Smith: I’ll piggyback off question 7 because I, too, am a parent. My oldest son was the starting point guard on the 2020 WPIAL championship team. He went on to play Division III basketball at Juniata, where he sat out two seasons. He worked, got stronger, bought into what his coaches were trying to build, and ultimately had a great experience at the next level. Today, he’s a trauma nurse at Ruby Memorial in West Virginia. His twin sister graduated from Lincoln Park, went on to play Division II basketball at Glenville State, won a national championship, and finished her college career as a 1,000-point scorer. Why were my kids successful? Because they put in the work. They trusted the process, bought into their coaches, and understood that success doesn’t happen overnight. College athletics are hard. Maintaining your grades while competing at any level is a tremendous accomplishment. Not everyone is going to play Division I, and that’s okay. There are incredible opportunities and experiences at every level of college athletics. That’s what I’m trying to build in this community. I want our kids to understand the value of hard work, commitment, accountability, education, and being part of something bigger than themselves. I want them to have opportunities beyond high school, whether that’s basketball or whatever path they choose. At the end of the day, I want our players to leave this program not only as better basketball players, but as better people, prepared for whatever comes next.

 

Q: Looking at your current Laurel Highlands program, what excites you most about the direction of the team, and what expectations do you have for the upcoming season?

John Smith: I’m really excited about our program from top to bottom. I feel like we have great coaches in place, starting with our third graders all the way through high school, and we’re finally starting to see the payoff. When I look down through the different age groups, I see multiple talented players in every class. That’s refreshing and gives me a lot of optimism for the future. I’ll also admit that I have a little extra excitement this year because my youngest son is a senior. I’m excited to see what he can accomplish in his final season. He earned First Team All-Section honors last year, and I know how much work he’s put in this offseason. He’s prepared, he’s motivated, and I know he’s ready to go. It’s going to be a special year!

 

Q: Coach, with Laurel Highlands competing in a section that includes traditional rivals like Uniontown, what do you believe it will take to compete for a section championship this season?

John Smith: We have to defend the ball. Every possession matters, and we can never overlook an opponent. We have some really nice pieces this year and, probably just as important, some depth coming off the bench. It’s going to be a dogfight most nights, but if we stay composed, disciplined, and committed to doing the little things, I believe we’ll put ourselves in a position to compete and have a chance to win just about every game. We have to be tough, trust each other, and bring it every night.

 

Q: When your coaching career eventually comes to an end, what do you hope your former players and the Laurel Highlands community will remember most about John Smith, beyond wins and championships?

John Smith: I would like to be remembered as someone who gave of himself, who genuinely cared about our kids, and who always tried to make a positive impact on the young people in our community. I hope I helped develop not just better basketball players, but better people. I also hope I carried on the long-standing traditions of Mustang basketball and represented our school, our community, and everyone who came before me with pride. This program is bigger than any one coach, player, or season. I’m just fortunate to have played a part in its history and hopefully helped build something that the next generation can be proud of. At the end of the day, the wins and losses will eventually fade, but the relationships, memories, lessons, and impact we leave on these kids are what really matter.

 

Final Thoughts

What I appreciate about this conversation is that Coach Smith understands something that sometimes gets lost in today’s high school sports environment.

Winning matters. Anybody who has competed at a high level understands that.

But a coach’s influence can extend far beyond the basketball court.

Smith’s journey from a 2-20 season to the WPIAL playoffs shows the progress his program has made, but his answers reveal that he’s measuring success in other ways, too.

He’s proud of the players who have gone on to college, the young people who have developed through the program, and the relationships he’s built within a community he calls home.

And as Laurel Highlands prepares for another basketball season, Smith has an opportunity to continue building on that foundation.

I want to thank Coach John Smith for taking the time to participate in this Q&A and sharing his perspective on basketball, coaching, parenting, and the responsibility that comes with leading young athletes.

Related Post

Lou Cerro Deserves His Flowers: Four WPIAL Championships and Over 200 Career Wins

When people discuss the greatest high school football coaches in WPIAL history, certain names always

Brian Mangiafico: The Magic Man Who Took Pennsylvania High School Football by Storm in 1991

When you go back through Western Pennsylvania high school football history, you come across players

Barry Church: The Penn Hills NFL Standout Who Doesn’t Get Nearly Enough Recognition

When you start discussing the greatest football players to come out of Penn Hills, there

Q&A: Clairton Basketball Coach Rashawd Hatten Talks Bringing Pride Back to the Court, Mon Valley Basketball, and Building a Program Beyond Wins

When people think about Clairton athletics, football is usually the first sport that comes to

Q&A: Jonathan Baldwin: Before the NFL, Aliquippa Produced One of the Most Physically Gifted Athletes Western Pennsylvania Has Ever Seen

When you talk about the greatest athletes to ever come out of Aliquippa, Pennsylvania, you’re

Rich Bonnaure: A Championship Coach, But an Even Better Person — Why the Former South Fayette Coach Deserves His Flowers

When people discuss the greatest basketball coaches in WPIAL history, the conversation usually revolves around

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *