Western Pennsylvania football has produced so many NFL players that sometimes we forget about the guys who looked like they were headed in that same direction.
The recruits everybody wanted. The athletes who looked different standing next to everybody else. The players who went to major college programs and seemed to be right on schedule.
And then something happened.
For Devon Lyons, that something was an injury.
Before Ohio State, before the ankle injury and before people started wondering what could have been, Lyons was one of the most gifted football players to come through Woodland Hills during one of the greatest talent-producing stretches any Western Pennsylvania high school has ever had.
And that’s saying something.
Being Special at Woodland Hills Meant Something
You have to understand Woodland Hills football during this era.
This wasn’t a program where becoming a Division I recruit automatically made you unusual. Woody High was producing them constantly.
From the late 1980s through the 2000s, the list is ridiculous.
Steve Breaston. Ryan Mundy. Shawntae Spencer. Lousaka Polite. Rob Gronkowski. Darrin Walls. And plenty more.
A Pittsburgh Post-Gazette study of recruiting from 1989 through 2023 found Woodland Hills to be the area’s king of major-college football production.
So when you became one of the most highly regarded players at Woodland Hills, you were doing something.
Devon Lyons was doing something. 23 Catches. 14 Touchdowns. This is the statistic that immediately jumped out at me.
As a senior at Woodland Hills, Lyons caught 23 passes for 756 yards.
Fourteen of those catches went for touchdowns.
Read that again.
23 receptions. 14 touchdowns. More than half of his catches ended in the end zone.
That’s absurd.
This wasn’t today’s spread-football world where receivers might see 15 targets in one game. Woodland Hills played physical Western Pennsylvania football.
When Lyons got an opportunity, he made something happen. That’s why he earned a spot on the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Fabulous 22.
That’s why major colleges noticed.
And He Wasn’t Just a Receiver
Here’s where the athletic ability really starts showing.
Lyons played both ways. As a senior defensive back, he recorded 52 tackles and four interceptions. The year before, he had 49 tackles, five interceptions and five forced fumbles.
Then look at the track speed. Lyons ran a 10.9 in the 100 meters and 22.8 in the 200.
And he was doing all of this at roughly 6-foot-4. Size. Speed. Ball skills. Defensive ability. That’s why national recruiting services viewed him as one of the country’s top prospects.
SuperPrep ranked him the No. 12 wide receiver in America and the fourth-best overall prospect in Pennsylvania. Other recruiting services rated him among the country’s top safety prospects.
Ohio State wanted him.
And Lyons went to Columbus.
Then He Played as a True Freshman
This is an important part of the story.
Ohio State wasn’t some rebuilding program desperately throwing freshmen onto the field. This was Ohio State.
And Devon Lyons played in all 12 games as a true freshman in 2004.
As the season progressed, he worked his way into the receiver rotation and started receiving significant playing time.
Going into his sophomore season, Ohio State’s own evaluation said Lyons had “all the tools to be a standout.”
That’s when you start thinking: Here we go. Western Pennsylvania kid. National recruit. Ohio State. Played immediately. Now he’s about to take the next step.
Except sports don’t always follow the script.
Then Came the Ankle
Lyons played in Ohio State’s first two games of the 2005 season.
Then he injured his left ankle in practice before the San Diego State game. He missed the remainder of the season.
Ten games gone. That’s where the “what if?” begins.
Because injuries don’t simply take away games.
They can take away development. They can take away repetitions. They can change depth charts. They can allow another highly recruited player to take your spot.
And at a place like Ohio State, there is always another elite player waiting.
That’s the part people sometimes don’t understand about major college football.
When you’re at a powerhouse, the train doesn’t stop because you’re injured.
What If Devon Lyons Never Hurts That Ankle?
That’s the question.
Before the injury, Ohio State expected Lyons to become one of its top receivers.
He was 6-foot-4. He could run. He had already shown big-play ability at Woodland Hills. He had played as a freshman.
So what happens with a healthy sophomore season? Does he break out? Does he eventually become an All-Big Ten receiver? Does he become an NFL Draft pick?
Maybe. Maybe not. Nobody can honestly answer that. But there’s enough evidence to make the question legitimate.
This wasn’t somebody Pittsburgh simply thought was good. One of the premier college football programs in America thought he could become a standout too.
And Look at the Receivers Ohio State Was Producing
This makes the timing even more fascinating.
Ohio State was putting serious receivers into professional football during that period. Michael Jenkins. Santonio Holmes. Ted Ginn Jr. Anthony Gonzalez.
This was an environment producing NFL talent. Imagine staying healthy, developing inside that receiver room and getting your opportunity.
That’s why one injury can completely change the direction of a career.
At another school, maybe you get your position back immediately.
At Ohio State? There are four more dudes behind you who were stars in high school too.
Imagine Devon Lyons Today
Now take the Woodland Hills version of Devon Lyons and put him in 2026.
A 6-foot-4 athlete running a 10.9 hundred. Playing receiver and defensive back. Catching 23 passes and turning 14 of them into touchdowns.
Those highlights would be ridiculous. Every recruiting account would post him. People would debate whether he should play receiver or safety in college. His track videos would circulate alongside his football highlights. He’d attend national camps and combines. Every measurable would become content. And every touchdown would live permanently online.
But that’s another reason I’m doing this series.
A lot of Western Pennsylvania monsters played during an era where their greatness wasn’t permanently stored on everybody’s phone.
Woodland Hills Has So Many NFL Players That Guys Like Lyons Can Get Lost
This might be the most interesting part of Devon Lyons’ story.
If he came from a school that rarely produced major Division I recruits, people might still talk constantly about him. But Woodland Hills produced so many elite players that history can almost swallow somebody.
Think about how crazy that is.
You can be one of Pennsylvania’s top recruits, sign with Ohio State, play as a true freshman and somehow become a name younger Western Pennsylvania football fans might barely recognize.
That’s not because Devon Lyons wasn’t talented. It’s because Woodland Hills’ talent pipeline was absurd.
Don’t Judge the Beginning By the Ending
That’s one lesson I keep coming back to with this series.
People look up an athlete, see what happened in college or the pros and then retroactively decide how good that athlete must have been in high school.
Sports don’t work that way.
An injury at 19 doesn’t make you less dominant at 17. A college depth chart doesn’t erase what you did on Friday nights. Not reaching the NFL doesn’t mean NFL talent wasn’t once a possibility.
Devon Lyons was one of the country’s most highly regarded high school football prospects. He earned that.
He went to Ohio State. He played immediately. He earned that too.
Then his path changed.
That’s Why He’s a “What If?”
There are different kinds of “what if?” athletes.
Some never receive the opportunity. Some make decisions that change their careers. Some struggle academically. Some are simply born in the wrong era.
And some appear to be headed exactly where everybody expected until their body interrupts the journey.
Devon Lyons belongs in that category.
Maybe a healthy ankle changes nothing. Or maybe we’re talking today about another Woodland Hills player who made it all the way to Sundays.
We’ll never know.
But go back to 2004. Forget what happened afterward.
Picture a 6-foot-4 Western Pennsylvania athlete with legitimate track speed who scored touchdowns on 14 of his 23 catches, intercepted passes on defense and was headed to Ohio State.
Now ask yourself: What did everybody think the ceiling was then?
That’s the story.
And that’s why Devon Lyons deserves his flowers.
This is Part 9 of DrewSchifino.com’s series, “Pittsburgh’s Greatest ‘What If?’ Athletes,” preserving the stories of Western Pennsylvania athletes whose talent deserves to be remembered.