I’m going to make a statement that some Steelers fans might disagree with.
Sunday night’s game against the Cincinnati Bengals is the biggest game of Pittsburgh’s season. And it’s not even close.
Both teams enter the matchup with identical 6-2 records, sitting at the top of the AFC North. The winner takes control of the division race and puts itself in an excellent position to eventually secure a home playoff game.
Remember, winning your division guarantees a top-four seed in the AFC playoffs. And when you look at how the rest of the schedule sets up for both teams, Sunday’s outcome could have enormous consequences.
But there’s another reason I’m watching this game closely. I want to find out if the Pittsburgh Steelers’ defense is really as good as people think it is.
Because while Pittsburgh has been winning football games, I have some legitimate questions about the quality of offenses they’ve been facing.
And Sunday night, against Joe Burrow and Cincinnati, those questions are going to get answered.
Pittsburgh Has Been Winning, But Let’s Look at Who They’ve Beaten
First, give the Steelers credit.
You don’t apologize for winning in the NFL. Pittsburgh has won four consecutive games and enters this matchup coming off a bye week.
That’s impressive.
But here’s what I always tell people when evaluating a football team.
You have to look beyond the record. You have to examine the competition.
During Pittsburgh’s four-game winning streak, the Steelers defeated Indianapolis, Tampa Bay, New Orleans, and Cleveland. Those teams entered this week with a combined record of 13-22. Only Cleveland had a winning record.
Now, does that mean Pittsburgh’s victories don’t count?
Absolutely not. But it does mean we need to be careful about declaring this defense elite based solely on recent results.
There’s a difference between shutting down an offense that struggles to move the football and containing a legitimate Super Bowl-caliber quarterback.
There’s a difference between facing an inconsistent passing attack and lining up against Joe Burrow.
And there’s a difference between beating teams you’re supposed to beat and proving you can consistently compete against the best offenses in football.
That’s why Sunday matters so much.
Joe Burrow Is a Completely Different Challenge
Let’s talk about what Pittsburgh is facing.
Joe Burrow is playing outstanding football. Through eight games, he’s thrown for 2,386 yards and 23 touchdowns. He’s completing approximately 74 percent of his passes. And Cincinnati is averaging 30 points per game, ranking second in the NFL.
Those aren’t ordinary offensive numbers. That’s an explosive passing attack led by one of the best quarterbacks in football.
And when Burrow has time to throw, he can make even the best defenses look ordinary.
That’s what separates elite quarterbacks from average ones. You can disguise your coverage. You can bring pressure. You can try to confuse them before the snap. But the great ones can recognize what you’re doing and find ways to beat it.
Pittsburgh isn’t going to be able to depend on Cincinnati making the same mistakes that struggling offenses make.
Burrow can punish defensive breakdowns. He can recognize mismatches. And he has the weapons to turn one mistake into a touchdown.
This is the kind of matchup that tells you exactly where your defense stands.
Pittsburgh’s Defense Has the Numbers — Now I Want to See It Against Elite Competition
Here’s what makes this game interesting.
The Steelers have 26 sacks through eight games, ranking among the league leaders. They’ve also forced turnovers and done a good job putting their offense in favorable situations.
Those are legitimate accomplishments.
But statistics don’t always tell the entire story. Sometimes defensive numbers are influenced by the quarterbacks and offenses you’ve faced. A quarterback who holds the football too long makes your pass rush look better. An offense that struggles to protect its quarterback gives your defense more opportunities. And a team that can’t consistently move the chains makes your defensive statistics look impressive.
That’s why I want to see Pittsburgh against Cincinnati.
Can the Steelers generate pressure without constantly blitzing? Can their secondary hold up against quality receivers? Can they get off the field on third down? Can they prevent explosive plays? And most importantly, can they make Joe Burrow uncomfortable for four quarters?
Because if Pittsburgh can contain Cincinnati’s passing attack, I’ll give that defense all the credit in the world.
But if Burrow starts picking them apart, we’re going to have to reevaluate some of the praise this defense has been receiving.
That’s not hating. That’s evaluating football.
The First Meeting Should Tell Pittsburgh Something
Let’s not forget these teams already played earlier this season.
Pittsburgh defeated Cincinnati 30-27 in Week 3. That was an important victory.
But here’s what stands out to me. The Bengals still scored 27 points. Pittsburgh won the game, but it wasn’t as if the Steelers completely shut down Cincinnati’s offense.
And now the second meeting takes place in Cincinnati on Sunday Night Football.
The Bengals have an opportunity to even the season series. The Steelers have an opportunity to sweep their biggest competition for the division title.
That’s a major difference.
If Pittsburgh wins, it will own both head-to-head victories against Cincinnati. That could become extremely important if the teams finish with similar records.
But if Cincinnati wins, the season series will be split, and the division race becomes much more complicated.
That’s why I believe this game could ultimately decide who wins the AFC North.
Both Teams Have Opportunities Down the Stretch
Another reason Sunday’s matchup is so important is the remaining schedule.
Neither team faces an impossible road to the playoffs. Cincinnati still has games against Washington, New Orleans, Cleveland, Kansas City, and Carolina, among others.
There are winnable games on that schedule, although Kansas City certainly presents a major challenge.
Pittsburgh also has opportunities to build on its record, but the Steelers still have difficult matchups, including Jacksonville and Denver. So I wouldn’t automatically call Pittsburgh’s remaining schedule easy.
What I will say is that both teams have enough winnable games remaining that a head-to-head advantage could become extremely valuable.
And when two teams are this close in the standings, one game can change everything.
That’s especially true when they’re competing for the same division championship.
Aaron Rodgers Has to Do His Part, Too
While I’m focused on Pittsburgh’s defense, we can’t ignore the offense.
Aaron Rodgers has thrown for 1,871 yards and 13 touchdowns through eight games. Pittsburgh is averaging 22.5 points per game. Cincinnati is averaging 30.
That’s a significant difference.
And if Sunday’s game turns into a shootout, can Pittsburgh keep up? That’s a legitimate question.
The Steelers can’t expect their defense to hold Joe Burrow to 10 points. That’s not realistic. Rodgers and the offense have to sustain drives.
They have to finish possessions with touchdowns instead of settling for field goals. And they have to keep Burrow standing on the sideline as much as possible.
Pittsburgh’s running game could be especially important. Cincinnati has struggled to stop the run, and the Steelers have an opportunity to take advantage of that weakness.
If Pittsburgh can control the clock, establish the running game, and keep its defense fresh, it gives itself a much better opportunity.
But if the Steelers fall behind early and have to abandon the run, that’s a completely different football game.
This Is About More Than Winning the Division
Here’s something else Steelers fans need to understand.
Winning the AFC North is important. Making the playoffs is important. But at some point, this franchise has to start measuring success by something bigger.
Playoff victories.
The Steelers have gone nearly a decade without winning a postseason game. That’s not the standard this organization built its reputation on.
And that’s why I’m not interested in celebrating a good regular-season record without asking whether the team is capable of beating legitimate contenders.
We’ve seen Pittsburgh put together respectable seasons before. We’ve seen them win games against inferior opponents. We’ve seen them enter the playoffs with optimism. And we’ve seen those seasons end without a postseason victory.
At some point, the question has to change. Not just, “Can the Steelers make the playoffs?” But, “Can the Steelers actually beat the teams they’ll have to face once they get there?”
Sunday night gives us an opportunity to learn something about that.
Because Cincinnati has the kind of quarterback and passing attack Pittsburgh could encounter in January.
If the Steelers want to be taken seriously as an AFC contender, this is exactly the type of challenge they need to handle.
Sunday Night Will Tell Us a Lot
I believe the winner of Sunday’s game puts itself in the driver’s seat to win the AFC North.
And with a division championship comes a top-four playoff seed and a home postseason game.
Nothing will be officially decided Sunday night. There will still be plenty of football left.
But make no mistake about it. This is a huge game.
For Cincinnati, it’s an opportunity to protect its home field, split the season series, and take control of the division standings. For Pittsburgh, it’s an opportunity to sweep the Bengals, strengthen its position in the AFC North, and prove that its defense can perform against an elite quarterback.
And that’s what I’ll be watching.
Not just the final score. I’ll be watching how Pittsburgh’s defense responds when Joe Burrow starts attacking it.
I’ll be watching whether the Steelers can pressure him consistently. I’ll be watching how their secondary handles Cincinnati’s receivers. And I’ll be watching whether Aaron Rodgers can produce enough offense to keep Pittsburgh competitive if the Bengals start scoring.
Because I already know the Steelers can beat struggling football teams. What I want to know is whether they can consistently beat good ones.
There’s a big difference.
And Sunday night in Cincinnati, we’re going to find out a lot more about what kind of football team Pittsburgh really has.
The Steelers are 6-2. The Bengals are 6-2. First place is on the line.
But for Pittsburgh, something else is on the line.
Credibility.
Because if this defense is as good as Steelers fans believe it is, Sunday night is the perfect opportunity to prove it.
Winning games gets you into the playoff conversation. Beating elite competition proves you belong there.
And that’s why I believe this is Pittsburgh’s biggest game of the season.