WPIAL WHAT IF? Episode 1: What If Jim Render’s 1988 Upper St. Clair Team Had Played for the First PIAA State Championship?

There are certain moments in WPIAL sports history that make you wonder how differently things could have turned out if just one decision had gone another way.

Not a missed field goal. Not a controversial penalty. Not a last-second touchdown.

I’m talking about a decision made before a team ever stepped onto the field.

And one of the most fascinating examples involves legendary Upper St. Clair football coach Jim Render and the 1988 Panthers.

A team that won the WPIAL Class AAAA championship. A team that had already beaten Pittsburgh Central Catholic. And a team that never got the opportunity to compete for Pennsylvania’s first state football championship.

Why?

Because Upper St. Clair decided not to participate in the inaugural PIAA playoffs.

Central Catholic went instead. And won the whole thing.

Nearly 40 years later, I still find myself wondering about that decision. What if Jim Render and Upper St. Clair had played in the 1988 state playoffs? Could we be talking about back-to-back state championships for one of the greatest coaches in WPIAL history?

 

Before 1988, Winning the WPIAL Was Everything

One thing I always try to do when discussing sports history is understand the era.

It’s easy to look back at something that happened decades ago and judge it using today’s standards. But you have to remember what high school football was like in Western Pennsylvania before 1988.

The WPIAL championship was everything. That was the ultimate prize.

You spent your summer preparing, battled through your conference schedule, survived the playoffs, and if you were fortunate enough to win a WPIAL championship, you had reached the mountaintop.

There wasn’t another tournament waiting afterward. There wasn’t a state championship game in Hershey.

For generations, the WPIAL championship was the final destination.

And let’s be clear about something. Winning the WPIAL, especially in the old Quad-A classification, was no small accomplishment.

Those conferences were loaded. Those playoff brackets were brutal. You had to survive some of the best football programs in Pennsylvania just to call yourself a WPIAL champion.

So when the PIAA introduced statewide football playoffs in 1988, not everybody was excited about the idea. There were concerns about extending the season, additional games, and whether a statewide tournament was even necessary.

Nobody knew what those playoffs would eventually become. Nobody knew that future generations would consider state championships such an important part of a program’s legacy.

And that brings us to Upper St. Clair.

 

Upper St. Clair Won the WPIAL Championship — Then Stopped Playing

Jim Render had built Upper St. Clair into one of the premier football programs in Western Pennsylvania.

The Panthers were disciplined, physical, fundamentally sound, and accustomed to winning. In 1988, they captured the WPIAL Class AAAA championship by defeating Pittsburgh Central Catholic. Under today’s system, that victory would have sent Upper St. Clair into the state playoffs.

But 1988 wasn’t today.

Upper St. Clair’s school board had already decided the Panthers would not participate in the new statewide tournament. That decision had been made before the playoffs began.

And despite winning the WPIAL championship, the Panthers’ season was over.

Imagine that happening today. Imagine a team winning the WPIAL championship and then announcing it wasn’t going to compete for a state title.

People would lose their minds.

But that’s how different the thinking was in 1988.

And I don’t necessarily believe the people involved understood the historical significance of what they were turning down.

How could they?

The state playoffs had never existed before. They were making a decision based on what football meant at that particular time.

Not what it would mean 40 years later.

 

Central Catholic Took Their Place and Made History

This is where the story gets really interesting.

Pittsburgh Central Catholic had just lost to Upper St. Clair in the WPIAL championship game.

Under normal circumstances, its season would have been finished. But because Upper St. Clair wasn’t participating in the state playoffs, Central Catholic received the opportunity.

And the Vikings didn’t waste it.

Central Catholic defeated Brashear, 19-14, in the western portion of the state tournament. Then the Vikings faced Cedar Cliff for the inaugural PIAA Class AAAA championship.

Central Catholic won, 14-7.

Just like that, Pittsburgh Central Catholic became Pennsylvania’s first Class AAAA state football champion.

Think about the historical significance.

The team that lost the WPIAL championship became the state champion. The team that beat them never participated. And nearly four decades later, Central Catholic’s name remains permanently attached to that first championship.

I want to make something perfectly clear.

I’m not taking anything away from Central Catholic. They earned that championship. They accepted the opportunity, won their games, and brought the first Class AAAA state title back to Western Pennsylvania.

But that doesn’t mean we can’t ask the obvious question.

If Upper St. Clair was good enough to beat Central Catholic, how far could the Panthers have gone in that same tournament?

 

Jim Render Is One of the Greatest Coaches in WPIAL History

When you talk about legendary WPIAL football coaches, Jim Render is always in the conversation.

More than 400 career victories. Five WPIAL championships at Upper St. Clair. Two PIAA state championships. Decades of consistency. And a reputation for building teams that were disciplined, prepared, and extremely difficult to beat.

I’ve always respected coaches who build programs that remain successful across multiple generations.

Anybody can have one talented senior class. Anybody can catch lightning in a bottle for a season or two. But maintaining a championship-level program for decades is something entirely different.

That’s what Render accomplished. And that’s why the 1988 decision fascinates me.

I don’t know Coach Render personally.

I’ve never had the opportunity to sit down with him and discuss that season. So I’m not going to pretend I know what he was thinking or how he feels about it today.

But I know one thing.

You don’t win more than 400 football games without being an incredible competitor. And knowing how competitors think, I can’t help but wonder whether 1988 is one season he wishes he could revisit.

Not because Upper St. Clair failed.

They didn’t. They won the WPIAL championship.

But because there was another championship available, and they never got the chance to compete for it.

Sometimes the games that stay with competitors aren’t necessarily the ones they lose. Sometimes they’re the ones they never got to play.

 

Then Came 1989 — And Everything Changed

Here’s what makes this particular What If? even more fascinating.

One year later, Upper St. Clair returned with another outstanding football team. And this time, the Panthers participated in the PIAA playoffs.

What happened?

They went undefeated. 15-0. WPIAL Class AAAA champions. PIAA Class AAAA state champions. And they finished ranked No. 4 nationally by USA Today.

That 1989 team was absolutely loaded.

Doug Whaley and Pete Habib helped lead the running game. Phil Dunn was a force up front. Kevin Orie was another outstanding athlete on the roster.

And in the state championship game, Upper St. Clair defeated Wilson of West Lawn, 12-7. That Wilson team featured future NFL quarterback Kerry Collins.

Upper St. Clair became the first WPIAL team to finish 15-0 and win the state Class AAAA championship.

That’s not just a great WPIAL team. That’s one of the greatest teams in Western Pennsylvania high school football history.

And it happened one year after Upper St. Clair declined to participate in the first state playoffs.

Now tell me that doesn’t make you wonder.

 

Could Upper St. Clair Have Won Back-to-Back State Championships?

This is the million-dollar question.

If Upper St. Clair had participated in the 1988 PIAA playoffs, could Jim Render have won back-to-back state championships in 1988 and 1989?

I believe the possibility was absolutely there. And I think the strongest argument is pretty simple.

Upper St. Clair had already defeated the team that eventually won the 1988 state championship.

That’s not speculation. That actually happened.

Now, does that guarantee Upper St. Clair would have beaten Brashear and Cedar Cliff? Of course not.

Football doesn’t work that way.

Just because you beat one team doesn’t automatically mean you would beat everybody that team defeated.

Different matchups. Different styles. Different circumstances.

And that’s what makes sports so unpredictable.

But I do believe Upper St. Clair would have been a legitimate contender.

And considering what Render accomplished the following season, it’s difficult not to imagine what those two years could have looked like.

Instead of one state championship in 1989, maybe Upper St. Clair wins two consecutive titles. Maybe Render becomes the first coach to win back-to-back PIAA Class AAAA championships. Maybe that 1988 team receives the same historical recognition as the legendary 1989 squad.

Or maybe Upper St. Clair enters the tournament and loses. We’ll never know.

And that’s the beauty of a What If? discussion.

You can debate the possibilities without changing what actually happened.

 

I Wonder If Render Would Make the Same Decision Today

This is the part of the story that interests me most.

I wonder what Jim Render would say if somebody asked him about 1988 today.

Would he say the decision was understandable because of the circumstances? Would he say winning the WPIAL championship was enough? Or would he admit that, looking back, he wishes his players had received the opportunity to compete for the first state title?

Again, I don’t know.

And there’s an important distinction here.

The decision not to participate came from Upper St. Clair’s school board. It wasn’t simply Jim Render deciding he didn’t want to coach another football game.

In fact, contemporary accounts indicate that Render encouraged his players to accept the decision and move forward.

That speaks to his leadership.

But accepting a decision in 1988 and wondering about it decades later are two entirely different things.

And that’s what I’d love to ask him.

Because if there’s one thing I’ve learned from competing at a high level, it’s that opportunities matter.

When you’re young, you sometimes assume there will always be another season. Another championship. Another chance.

But nothing in sports is guaranteed.

You never know when you’ll have that particular group of players together again.

And sometimes you don’t fully appreciate the significance of an opportunity until years later.

 

The Decision That Changed Two Programs’ Histories

Think about how one decision affected the historical records of two of Western Pennsylvania’s greatest football programs.

Central Catholic became the first PIAA Class AAAA champion. Upper St. Clair became the second in 1989. Both programs went on to build remarkable championship traditions.

But imagine if Upper St. Clair had participated in 1988 and won.

The Panthers would have been the inaugural champions. Central Catholic’s first state championship would have come in a different season.

Render’s legacy would include a potentially historic back-to-back accomplishment.

And the conversation surrounding those late-1980s Upper St. Clair teams might be even greater than it already is.

One decision. Made before the postseason. And nearly 40 years later, we’re still talking about it.

That’s what makes sports history so fascinating to me.

Sometimes the biggest turning points don’t happen on the field. They happen in meeting rooms, school board discussions, and decisions that seem relatively ordinary at the time.

Nobody making that decision in 1988 could have known how much the PIAA playoffs would eventually mean.

But history has a way of making ordinary decisions look extraordinary decades later.

 

The Championship That Never Got a Chance

I’ve always believed Jim Render belongs among the greatest coaches in WPIAL football history. His accomplishments speak for themselves.

And whether Upper St. Clair participated in the 1988 state playoffs or not, nothing changes what he built.

But I can’t help thinking about that season. Especially knowing what happened in 1989.

Upper St. Clair beat Central Catholic for the WPIAL championship in 1988. Central Catholic went on to win the state championship.

Then Upper St. Clair came back the following year and went 15-0, winning both the WPIAL and PIAA titles.

That’s an incredible sequence of events.

And if I ever have the opportunity to interview Coach Render, I know exactly what I’m going to ask him.

Coach, if you could go back to 1988 knowing what you know today, would you want that team to play for the first PIAA state championship?

Maybe his answer would surprise me. Maybe he wouldn’t change a thing.

But I know if I were in that position, as a competitor, I’d want to find out just how far we could have gone. Because championships are special.

But the opportunity to compete for one is something you can never get back.

And that brings me to the question I want to leave with WPIAL football fans. WHAT IF Jim Render’s 1988 Upper St. Clair team had entered the PIAA playoffs?

Would the Panthers have beaten Brashear and Cedar Cliff? Would Upper St. Clair have won back-to-back state championships in 1988 and 1989? Or would Central Catholic have found a way to make history regardless?

We’ll never know.

But it’s one of the most fascinating unanswered questions in WPIAL football history.

And that’s why it’s Episode 1 of my WPIAL What If? series.

Related Post

Lou Cerro Deserves His Flowers: Four WPIAL Championships and Over 200 Career Wins

When people discuss the greatest high school football coaches in WPIAL history, certain names always

Melvin Kirby: From Penn Hills Football Star to Entrepreneur and Mentor — A Legacy Beyond the Game

The first kid I met when I started school at Penn Hills was Melvin Kirby.

Brian Mangiafico: The Magic Man Who Took Pennsylvania High School Football by Storm in 1991

When you go back through Western Pennsylvania high school football history, you come across players

John Smith: Building More Than a Basketball Program at Laurel Highlands

When people talk about Laurel Highlands basketball, the conversation often starts with the program’s championship

Barry Church: The Penn Hills NFL Standout Who Doesn’t Get Nearly Enough Recognition

When you start discussing the greatest football players to come out of Penn Hills, there

Q&A: Clairton Basketball Coach Rashawd Hatten Talks Bringing Pride Back to the Court, Mon Valley Basketball, and Building a Program Beyond Wins

When people think about Clairton athletics, football is usually the first sport that comes to

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *